atkins case Edward versus lewis July in the case of lease from college and  ecclesiastical body if the lessee in the new take in the right of he who be  the owner of the old he must take subject to all the equity to which the  original lease be liable David Edward by his will give his real estate to his  wife for life remainder to the plaintiff and after devise the personal estate  in the first place for payment of his debt he bequeathe the residue to his  wife who on his death enter upon a leasehold estate under queen college and  then intermarries with the defendant who after her death take out  administration de good non to the first testator but find the outgo of the  leasehold exceed the profit and be of no service but to the plaintiff he  freehold land be intermix with the leasehold neglect to apply for the renewal  but tacit consent the plaintiff shall renew who accord get a new lease from  the college the old one be suffer to run out the question here be suppose the  rest of the personal estate shall fall short to pay the testator debt whether  the plaintiff will be liable to pay those debt by virtue of his be in  possession of these leasehold premise Lord chancellor I be incline to be of  opinion that if the personal estate of the testator fall short the leasehold  estate in the hand of the plaintiff be subject to pay the creditor the residue  of their debt or otherwise by this neglect of the administrator or by  collusion between he and the plaintiff the creditor may be defeat of their  just debt but as it be probable in take the account of the testator personal  estate there may be sufficient foe pay the testator debt without have recourse  to the leasehold I shall not give a absolute opinion but only observe in  general that in case of lease from college and ecclesiastical body there be  nothing the court have more adhere to than if the tenant who in a constant  course of let be entitle to a college lease or any person claim from that  tenant apply either before it expire to renew or after it be actual expire and  surrender the old lease for that purpose yet whether the new lease be grant to  the same person or any other if the lessee in the new take in the right of he  who be the owner of the old lease he must take subject to all the equity to  which the original lessee be liable see the case cite in Pierson v shore atk  Lord chancellor order a account to be take of the testator personal estate and  reserve the consideration how far the renew lease of the land hold of queen  college in Cambridge be liable to be apply towards satisfaction of the  testator debt and legacy till after it shall be atkins see whether the fund  before mention be sufficient to pay his debt and legacy atkins er p