ambler case jefferys against baldwin in chancery march demurrer to discovery  for that plaintiff have not make such a case as entitle he to such discovery  on argue the demurrer the court be of opinion the plaintiff be not entitle to  relief allow the demurrer though it be to the discovery only No entry in lib  Reg bill bring on statute Geo c set forth that plaintiff have procure a draw  or design to be make of the buss of the society of British herring fishery  that defendant have print the same in the London magazine and pray discovery  and injunction not to sell for the future plaintiff wave all penalty two  demurrer by defendant saint as to so much of the bill as pray discovery that  it appear by plaintiff own show in his bill that such discovery will subject  defendant to several penalty inflict by the act of parliament in the say bill  mention and for that the plaintiff have not make such a case by the say bill  as will entitle he to any such discovery and therefore ought not to be compel  to answer d demurrer as to such part as pray that the defendant may be  restrain from sell for the future or seek any relief plaintiff have not make  such a case by his bill as will entitle he to such or any other relief on  argue the demurrer two objection by defendant saint that it be not a work of  ingenuity of plaintiff and therefore not within the statute but state that he  procure it to be do d that by the statute half the penalty go to the crown and  the other moiety go to the informer and the plaintiff can wave the whole but  only his share Lord Hardwicke c the plaintiff have not make a case for relief  therefore need not go into the question as to discovery it be not within the  statute which be make for encouragement of genius and art if it be any person  who employ a printer the engraver will be so too this statute be in that  respect like statute of new invention from whence it be take if be can claim  property he be not entitle to relief which will only enable he to sue at law  bill be frivolous allow demurrer Reg Min book march cur allow both demurrer it  be now settle that if a bill pray discovery and relief a plaintiff not entitle  to relief be not entitle to discovery fry v pen bro c c price v James ib dick  Watkins v bush ib baker v Mellish Ves Gordon v Simpkinson Ves pit v short Ves  attorneygeneral v brown Swanst see Lord Redesdale Tr see Blackwell v Harper  atk by Geo c the sole right to print c be vest for twentyeight year in all  person who invent design or engrave c it or from their own work design or  invention shall cause or procure to be design it engrave etch or work in  mezzotinto or chairo oscuro any print c Mr Eden in his treatise on injunction  page remark that the principal case be tender unimportant by the provision of  the above act Geo but qucere for it do not appear to extend to case where a  person procure a print to be make for he except it be from his own work design  or invention stat Geo c give a special action on the case to recover damage  for piracy of print and the assignee of a print may maintain such action  Thompson v simmonds t r ambler er p