case poor versus clark February where you draw the jurisdiction out of a court  of law you must have all the party before the court who be necessary to make  the determination complete and to quiet the question a bill be bring by a  lessee for year under the dean and chapter of Winchester against a Lord of a  manor and the tenant of a particular house that it may be pull down as it  obstruct the plaintiff way to his field and to be quiet in the possession of  the way for the future the defendant counsel object for want of party because  the dean and chapter of Winchester who be the owner of the inheritance be not  bring before the court Lord chancellor if the relief can be only temporary it  must be leave to law for in case of this kind the court will not interfere  unless they can make a last and permanent decree that shall for ever quiet and  settle the right and will not decree it for a particular term only the  plaintiff here may as well have be a tenant for one year as twentyone or even  a tenant at will if the question be concern a right of common though a  leaseholder may establish it at law yet if he bring a bill here to establish  such right be it ever do without have the owner of t inheritance before the  court the same rule hold upon a bill bring by a lessee for tithe or for  establish a modus mayor of York v Pilkington ante vol so be the practice of  the exchequer for the general rule be that if you draw the jurisdiction out of  a court of law you must have all person party before this court who atkins  will be necessary to make the determination complete and to quiet the question  paulet v bishop of Lincoln ante the case of bush versus western Prec in Ch be  different from the present because the defendant there rest entire upon a  forfeit mortgage and do not set forth who the owner of the inheritance be or  pray that he may be make a party upon the whole this be a good objection for  want of party as to the objection of not make the rest of the freeholder and  lessee of the manor party if they do not think proper to dispute the plaintiff  right the plaintiff be not oblige to bring they before the court but if they  shall not submit to the right he claim of the way a decree against the lord of  a manor will not bind copyholder in fee or freeholder for life but they may  controvert the right notwithstanding