coke a PINNELS case Trin Elizabeth rot in the common plea follow Foakes v beer  App Cas bidder v bridge Ch d payment of a less sum on the day in satisfaction  of a great can be any satisfaction for the whole the gift of a horse hawk robe  c in satisfaction be good payment of part before the day and acceptance may be  in satisfaction of the whole so payment of part at a different plAcc the  payment of part ought to be plead to be pay in full satisfaction it be not  sufficient to aver that it be accept in full satisfaction the manner of the  tender and of the payment shall be direct by he who make they not by he who  accept a acknowledgement of satisfaction by deed be a good bar without any  thing receive SC more see case in law c Lucas Pinnel bring a action of debt on  a bind against coal of for payment of S the ilth day of Nov the defendant  plead that be at the instance of the plaintiff before the say day sure I odob  year at W to loosen to express grief S d quas indeed S d the plaintiff a Doct  pl Bac ab accord sit a a accept in full satisfaction of the S and it be  resolve by the whole court that payment of a lesser sum on the day in  satisfaction of a great can be any satisfaction for the whole because it  appear to the judge that by no possibility b Perk sect   light b b a lesser  sum can be a satisfaction to the plaintiff for a great sum a so acceptance of  a security for a lesser sum can be plead in satisfaction of a similar security  for a great cumber v wane strange and per Lord Ellenborough fitch v Sutton  east though that case be say by I in argument in Heathcote v Crookshanks to  have be deny to be law and in confirmation of that Mr justice buller afterward  refer to a case yet I can find any case of that sort and none have now be  refer to on the contrary the decision in cumber v wane be direct support by  the authority of Pinnells case which never appear to have be question although  if a creditor simple agree to accept less from his debtor than his just demand  that will not bind he yet if upon the faith of such a agreement a three person  be induce to become surety for any part of the debt on the ground that the  party will be thereby discharge of the remainder of his debt and still more  when other creditor have be induce by the agreement to relinquish their  further demand upon the same supposition such agreement will be bind Sleinham  v Hagnes east and Vid Com dig accord Bac ab accord and satisfaction note c  barber v fox sand e that edition a but the gift of a horse c   a Perk sect    light b Yelv Bulstr Cr Elizabeth Cr James c hawk or robe c in satisfaction be  good for it shall be intend that a horse hawk or robe c may be more beneficial  to the plaintiff than the money in respect of some circumstance or otherwise  the plaintiff will not have accept of it in satisfaction but when the whole  sum be due by no intendment the acceptance of a   light b Yelv Perk sect Dall  pl more Lutw a parcel can be a satisfaction to the plaintiff but in the case  at bar it be resolve that the payment coke report b er p and acceptance of  parcel before the b more   light b Cr Elizabeth b day in satisfaction of the  whole will be a good satisfaction in regard of circumstance of time for  peradventure parcel of it before the day will be more beneficial to he than  the whole at the day and the value of the satisfaction be not material so if I  be bind in to pay you at Westminster c more Cr Elizabeth   light b Mod c and  you request I to pay you at the day at York and you will accept it in full  satisfaction of the whole it be a good satisfaction coke b for the whole for  the expense to pay it at York be sufficient satisfaction but in this case the  plaintiff have judgement for the insufficient plead for he do not plead that  he have pay the S d in full d   b Doct pl winch style d satisfaction as by the  law he ought but plead the payment of part general and that the plaintiff e  Doct pl Cr Elizabeth style e accept it in full satisfaction b that the sum  must be lead to have be give in full satisfaction Vid Frederick v Gosfright  Carth and also to have be accept in full satisfaction Vid drake v Mitchell  east and Vid post Peytoes case   b Francis v Crywell barn and Ald b and always  the manner of the tender and of the payment shall be direct f Cr Elizabeth  Browul style f by he who make the tender or payment and not by he who accept  it c where there be distinct account and a general payment and no  appropriation make at the time of such payment by the debtor the creditor may  apply such payment to which account he please but where payment be make upon  one entire account such payment be to be consider as payment in discharge of  the early item clayton case Meriv Bodenham v Purchas barn Ald c and for this  cause judgement be give for the plaintiff see reader g   b Dall pl g h bar in  debt on a bind of the defendant plead that one f be bind by the say deed with  he and each in the whole and that the plaintiff have make a acquittance to f  hear date before the obligation and deliver after by which acquittance he do  acknowledge himself to be pay S in full satisfaction of the and it be adjudge  a good bar for if a man acknowledge himself to be satisfy by h Doct pl   light  b Dall pl more send for east h deed it be a good bar without any thing receive  vide r bar h bar and h c