case jeffre against barrow in debt against a heir if the defendant plead riens  per dissent at the time of the original purchase and the plaintiff reply  sufficient land by dissent and the jury find that he have sufficient land by  dissent without find the value of the land a repleader shall be award S c pale  yellow this be a action of debt upon bind bring against the heir and upon  riens per dissent plead the plaintiff reply treat he have land c sufficient to  discharge c the jury find for the plaintiff videlicet that sufficient land to  discharge c do descend it be move in arrest of judgement that this plead be  ground upon will mary c that Act ought to have be exact pursue and then the  issue shall have be only whether any land descend and not the value of the  land and if the jury find for the plaintiff then the jury be to inquire of the  value Parker chief justice seem to incline to the defendant mere upon this  point that it do not appear by this verdict whether when the jury find the  descent of sufficient land they mean sufficient in respect to the debt in  equity or at commonlaw videlicet the penalty probable the jury intend the  equitable debt only whereas judgement must be give upon the penalty the modern  report plaintiff put himself to great hazard in this way of plead for though  it have be find that land be descend yet if these land be find insufficient  judgement must have be give for the defendant Powell justice doubt whether  this not be a immaterial issue but a material one and more it be not help by  Henry c he doubt likewise whether if it be not yet this be a issue appoint by  this Act and more it may not be supply by another inquisition by another jury  powys and Eyre justice be of another opinion as to this point for the statute  say the jury videlicet the jury that try the cause powys justice as to the  principal matter concur with Parker chief justice Eyre justice be of opinion  that this verdict be equivalent to a inquisition modern report er p the court  think that the end of the Act of parliament be to help the creditor in case of  alienation and also the heir that he may not run such a risk in plead riens  per descent as to subject himself to the payment of the whole if but a penny  be find to be descend a this case be argue a second time and the court it be  say award a repleader because it be part of the duty of the jury upon this  issue to find the value of the land which the defendant have by dissent S c  pale yellow Rep see the case of Redshaw v Hester Mod salk a easter term the  ten of queen whether in the court of chancery Simon Lord Harcourt Lord keeper  sir John Trevor Knt master of the roll