carpenter against marshal grant of duchy land may be without attornment but to  a feoff livery must be SC I side ray keb n s Lutw vide lev ejectment be try at  the bar and find special where the case be a lease for year be make by the  king of duchylands lie out of the countypalatine afterward king James I in the  seven year of his reign grant the reversion by the dutchyseal of the  countypalatine and the great seal to one under who the plaintiff claim but no  attornment be have king Charles I recite the say grant and that it be void  grant the reversion under the dutchyseal to the defendant to who the lessee  attorned and the lease be determine the lessor bring ejectment against the  defendant who have get the possession whereupon the sole question be whether  the land pass by the first patent be duchylands lie out of the countypalatine  levinz without attornment and it be argue in Hillary term car by Jones for the  plaintiff and Weston for the defendant and in easter term the that by Maynard  for the plaintiff and for the defendant and it be agree on both side that the  great seal and the countypalatine seal signify nothing in the case for by the  stat h c land with in the countypalatine must pass by the countypalatine seal  and land out of the county by the dutchyseal but the objection be that the  land of the duchy be sever from the crown by the statute of h n and I if Sess  n that at the pass of those land livery and attornment be necessary as in the  case of a subject for the king bas those land as duke and not as king but  afterward in the same easter term it be resolve by all the court that the land  pass by rant of the reversion without attornment and the grant under the  dutchyseal be a grant by record and passes the reversion as a fine videlicet  to divest the estate without attornment but not to make a privity to find a  action of waste c accord to the Inst but if the king will make a feoff thereof  livery ought to be make as in the case of a subject for this the king may do  by attorney and judgement be give for the plaintiff