case attorney general versus grant rector of saint Dunstan Lord chancellor  Parker liberty of the roll in Middlesex be within the parish of saint Dunstan  in the west London and contribute a five towards the repair of the say church  but have distinct overseer and maintain its poor separate be not entitle to a  share of the charity give by will or deed to the poor of saint Dunstan though  entitle to a five of all collection make at the church door or at sacrament a  information be bring in the name of the attorneygeneral at the relation of the  inhabitant of the roll liberty against the impropriator curate and overseer of  the poor of the parish of saint Dunstan in the west London for a account of  charity give by several will and deed to the poor of the say parish and as the  liberty of the roll be part of the parish of saint Dunstan and the inhabitant  of that liberty on the say parish church be late repair have be assess and pay  a five part towards the repair thereof videlicet pound out of pound therefore  it be pray that the roll liberty may have a five of all the charity by will or  peer William deed give to the poor of saint Dunstan as likewise of the  charitable collection make at the door of the church or at sacrament it seem  the parish of saint Dunstan with regard to such part thereof as be within the  city of London have separate officer both churchwarden and overseer and  maintain their poor separate in like manner that part which be within the  county of Middlesex and liberty of the roll have distinct officer for the poor  but as to the chapel that only belong to the master of the roll who ex  agreeableness give leave to the inhabitant of the liberty to come there Lord  Parker before the statute of the of Elizabeth there be no such officer as  overseer of the poor since which as that part of the parish of saint Dunstan  which lie in London have have distinct overseer make distinct rate and  maintain their poor separate this make they as a distinct parish for which  reason with respect to all gift of charity by will or deed give to the parish  of saint Dunstan in the west that part of the parish which lie in London must  have and enjoy the same exclusive of the roll liberty but as to all such gift  grant or devise before the statute of the Elizabeth as at that time the parish  and liberty be not separate by distinct officer and overseer of the poor the  liberty of the roll be then part of the parish shall have a proportion thereof  but the liberty have contribute to the repair of tile peer William er p church  and be real within that parish as to all collection of charity at the church  door or at the poor box or at the peer William monthly or other sacrament  which be in part give by the inhabitant of the roll liberty who have seat in  and repair to the church of saint Dunstan and forasmuch as the inhabitant of  the roll liberty pay towards the parson and lecturer of saint Dunstan there be  invacation time no preach at the roll chapel and contribute to the charity of  saint Dunstan so ought the poor of the roll liberty be part of the say parish  to have a proportionable share of those charity wherefore to the intent it may  be see whether this have be observe let the disposition of these last mention  charity be specify in a book contain the name of the person to who give and  for what purpose memorandum it be say in this case that as to the charity  money give at sacrament the parson be not bind to distribute it among the poor  of the say parish but may bestow it on any object of charity cur I will not  now determine this though sure if equal object of charity be to be find within  the parish they in reason ought to be prefer