case henry clavering appellant sir james clavering and other respondent that  January Mews dig twelve xv a make a voluntary settlement of land subject to a  annuity of pound to his young son in trust for his old son and his heir which  settlement do not contain any power of revocation the old son be dead the  father make another voluntary settlement of the same land to the use of  himself for life remainder to his young son for life remainder to trustee to  preserve etcetera remainder to the first and other son of his young son in  tail the first deed come to the hand of the old son heir and the other to the  second son who bring a bill to set aside the first both son have be otherwise  provide for it be hold in chancery that though both deed be voluntary yet the  consideration of be a young child be not sufficient to set aside the first  deed and this decree be affirm in the house of lord prece in Chan vern Eq can  ab c viner vol p can vol p can vol p can vol p can sir James Clavering Bart  have three son namely John James and the appellant Henry and one daughter name  jane and be seize in fee of the manor of Lemadon in the county of  Northumberland of pound per and by indenture of lease and release date the  that and saint of August convey the same to trustee and their heir in trust to  raise and pay a annuity of pound per and to his son Henry for life by  quarterly payment and the like annuity to his daughter jane for life both of  they to commence from his death and upon further trust to pay and apply the  surplus profit of the premise to John his old son and his heir and within one  month after the annuity shall cease to convey the premise to his say old son  John and his heir in February John the old son and heir apparent of sir James  die leave the respondent sir James his old son and heir at law brown by  indenture of lease and release date the that and that of march sir James  Clavering the father convey the say estate of Lemadon to other trustee and  their heir for the use of himself for life with remainder to the appellant for  life remainder to trustee to preserve the contingent remainder remainder to  the first and other son of the appellant in tail male with other remainder  over but subject to a power of revocation both these settlement remain in the  custody of sir James until his death and jane the daughter die in his lifetime  whereby her annuity of pound lapse and become void in December sir James  Clavering make his will whereby he give the appellant a legacy of pound  together with the arrear of rend due from the tenant of Lemadon and by such  will and a deed of appointment make pursuant thereto he direct his personal  estate to be lie out in the purchase of land and settle to the use of the  respondent sir James his grandson for life remainder to his first and other  son in tail male with other remainder over in march the testator die and the  two several settlement be then brown er p find among his write the appellant  in Michaelmas term exhibit his bill in the court of chancery against the  respondent sir James and other proper party in order to have the settlement of  set aside and the subsequent settlement of establish in Hilary term the cause  come on to be hear before the Lord keeper wright when the bill as to the  relief thereby seek against the settlement of be dismiss whereupon the  plaintiff counsel pray a decree for the arrear and grow payment of his annuity  of pound per annum under the say settlement which be decree accord and the  subsequent settlement of march be in the hand of the defendant sir James he be  order to produce it upon the trial of any action at law which may be bring by  the plaintiff within a year the plaintiff instead of try his title at law  appeal from the decree contend I cheshire that the settlement of ought to be  look upon as only a temporary provision for himself and his sister suitable to  the then situation of his father estate and to the provision which he about  the same time make for his other child but his estate be after that time great  increase he first give his daughter jane a mortgage of pound instead of her  annuity and then settle the Lemadon estate upon the appellant in lieu of his  annuity that on this account the deed of be keep in the father custody till  his death and he therefore may have cancel they or convey the premise to a  purchaser that those deed lodge the legal estate in trustee and leave a trust  in sir James the father which be the creature of a court in equity may be fit  mould accord to the declare and repeat intention of the owner that this  intention be manifest front the proof in the cause which show saint that the  father write with his own brown hand on the back of the deed of the settlement  of Lemadon and lie it up among his other family settlement where it be find  after his death dly that the father after the settlement of frequent declare  to his relation and friend and to the tenant of Lemadon on payment of their  rend that he have settle the say estate on the appellant that he shall be  their landlord and call it the appellant estate and constant call he to  inspect and understand the account of it and also declare that the appellant  shall never be a annuityman express his dislike of the ill consequence of give  child only annuity dly that the father in his last sickness give direction to  look after this estate for the appellant benefit and the very night before his  death declare that he have not only settle the say estate on the appellant but  have give he all the arrear by will that so he may not be destitute of present  subsistence that both the deed be prepare by the same trustee and counsel and  have the father be advice or in the least apprehend there can have be any  danger that the deed of may arise to defeat his intention declare by those of  several expedient may have be easy find out to have avoid the former deed at  least be may and doubtless will have provide for the appellant out of the  great estate which he otherwise dispose of by his will codicil and deed of  appointment in favour of the respondent sir James as a equivalent for the  estate in question and therefore inasmuch as provision for young child be  ordinary favour and consider as purchase it be hope that the decree will be  reverse the deed of establish and such further conveyance make of the Lemadon  estate as that it may be enjoy accord to the appellant father intention on the  other side it be argue h Penton that the settlement of be fair make and in  full force have no power of revocation therein contain and that as the  appellant who be a bachelor have a provision make thereby it be a very  extraordinary attempt to set it aside by a subsequent voluntary conveyance  make by the same person without any consideration and with a express power of  revocation and this against the heir of the family who be to support the  dignity of a baronet and that the appellant have in effect give judgement  against himself in decline to try his title at law when by the decree he have  liberty give he so to do after hear counsel on this appeal it be order and  adjudge that the same shall be dismiss and the decree therein complain of  affirm jour vol p brown er p