a endorsee of note to the amount of pound purchase in at a under value I e at  S in the pound petition for a Commission against the drawer object that such  creditor who come by his debt in this manner be not entitle to sue out a  Commission but Macclesfield c hold that he be plain a creditor just as if the  drawees have pay the bankrupt a under rate for they hill ex part lee will Rep  and his lordship hold that though they have be give without any consideration  yet they be now his debt and the legal right vest in the endorsee by in case  of a assignment of a bind for as much as such assignee not be the legal  creditor can not have take out a Commission a have the endorsement of the note  in the principal case be make after the bankruptcy it may be a quaere whether  such endorsee will be entitle to a Commission as not be a creditor for pound  or capable of take out a Commission at the time of the party become a bankrupt  per his lordship ibidem a a Commission of bankruptcy be supersede because  grant upon the petition of a assignee of a bind who though he be a equitable  yet be no legal creditor east Geo Medlicots case in canc strange will Rep  defendant become indebt to plaintiff in and afterward commit a Act of  bankruptcy upon which plaintiff be the petition creditor take out a Commission  against he and in order to overreach and make void as many of his conveyance  and Settlements c as possible the creditor on a bill file endeavour to prove  he a bankrupt as far backward as they can and do actual prove to the  satisfaction of the court that he commit a Act of bankruptcy in the year then  it become a question whether the Commission of bankruptcy and all that be do  under it be not wrong in regard that the debt of the petition creditor on  which it be ground be contract subsequent in time to the first Act of  bankruptcy after arg and time take to consider Talbot c dismiss the plaintiff  bill without prejudice a mich de goll and ware can in Eq tempt Talbot a but  this decree be reverse in the house of lord by the opinion of all the judge  Feb