case the countess OF Winchelsea against lady Maidstone a deed of gift make of  personal chattel be not good against creditor if the donor continue in  possession but if while they be so in his possession they be take in execution  and redeem for and on account of the donor they thereby become his absolute  property again and notwithstanding the deed of gift will pass to a legatee  under a bequest of all his personal estate c trover for good try at the bar by  a jury of ken upon the trial the case be thus the earl of Winchelsea in the  month of August make his will and thereby devise to the plaintiff all his  personal estate to pay his debt c modern the will be prove but immediate upon  the death of the earl and before he be bury the defendant who be marry to the  old son of the earl take possession of the house and good in the declaration  mention the plaintiff produce the will under the probate then she prove that  the good be appraise at eighteen hundred pound she produce a inventory of they  and prove that they be the same contain in the declaration she likewise give  evidence of the conversion the defendant produce a deed of gift of these good  make by the earl in the year habendum to trustee therein name for the use of  his then lady but since dead for the term of her natural life and afterward  that they shall be and remain to his child the counsel for the plaintiff admit  that though the same good for which the action be bring be likewise contain in  the deed of gift yet that deed can not be good against a creditor that the  earl be in debt a judgement be obtain against he and by a testatum become  facias his good be take in execution and sell by the sheriff in Hilary term  for eight hundred pound which be after this deed of gift it be prove that his  steward pay the money and redeem the good and the earl give he a bind for  repayment which be do and the bind cancel so that by this mean he have gain a  new property a copy of the testatum modern er p become facias be produce and  likewise the bill of sale by the sheriff and the bind cancel and thereupon the  plaintiff have a verdict