air v Willis April devise of residue of personal estate to his wife bar not  her claim to dower legacy by a father to a child entitle to a rentcharge out  of a estate devise to another the child still entitle to the rentcharge  supplement a man by his will take no notice of his wife right to dower make a  provision for her out of the personal estate by way of residue this be insist  upon to be a implication to bar her of dower Lord chancellor No case to that  purpose this differ great from noise v mordant and the several other case  since which the rule have be that if a provision even personal accord to  latter determination be make for a child who estate by the same will be devise  away if he claim under the will he can have the other but here by the claim of  dower the wife do not break in on the will and this be the strong as it be  only a residue which accidental benefit he may intend she shall have as well  as dower vesey senior suppose a child be entitle to a rentcharge or such a  interest out of a real estate belong t be father who make a provision for he  by legacy or portion and devise that real estate to another child without take  notice of the rentcharge that child vesey senior er p be entitle to the  rentcharge as the father do not show any intent to exclude it for that do not  defeat the devise which the court will nor suffer Reg lib a fol enter air v  cart in Prec Chan a devise of land by husband to wife who be entitle to dower  without say in recompense of it hold to be a voluntary gift and no bar of  dower and in brown husband give a annuity to his wife in lieu of all benefit  from his estate she elect her dower but lose the annuity Inst hark Edward Eq  Cas ab vern viner title devise Mod atk in brown a rentcharge be hold hot a bar  of dower unless so express or the intention appear by the value of the land be  too small to satisfy both Lord Loughborough say the law be settle and plain  that it depend on the language of the will see also Ves sen Ves jun and Ves